“What Am I — Qualia, Brahman, Neurons, or just Nothing?”
“If the senses were absent from birth, would a mind or personality ever form?”
Chat with SageA thought experiment exploring how intelligence, intellect, and reasoning are emergent patterns constructed from sensory datasets, whereas raw consciousness is fundamental. By examining congenital sensory impairment (being born deaf-blind and senseless), we distinguish between the brain's trained intellect and the underlying spark of living awareness.
Human intelligence and mental activities are emergent, dependent on sensory experience. A child is born, sees, hears, touches, smells, and tastes the world; through these inputs, neural networks are trained, patterns of correlation are formed, and a mental world starts being created. Intellect, thoughts, and reasoning are products of these sensory training loops.
For someone born with damaged or missing sensory apparatus—such as being blind and deaf from birth—their neural networks have not been trained on visual and audio data, and they cannot learn language in a conventional sense. Yet, something is undeniably alive in them. They still experience their own model of the world, proving that experience itself does not depend on conceptual intelligence.
This thought experiment exposes the error in equating intelligence and thoughts with consciousness. Intelligence is the complex pattern-matching of sensory datasets; consciousness is the fundamental, pre-reflective presence that remains fully alive even when the sensory apparatus is completely silent and the intellect has no material to construct a mind.
Recommended research papers, debates, and lectures